ACP, AP2 and UCP are the three open protocols most often named when people talk about AI agents buying things. They are not three versions of the same idea. ACP is mainly about checkout between an agent and a store, AP2 is about proving payment authorisation, and UCP is a broad commerce standard backed by most of the big retailers. This comparison is based on the specs and launch announcements, as of November 2026.

ACP vs AP2 vs UCP at a glance

ACP AP2 UCP
Full name Agentic Commerce Protocol Agent Payments Protocol Universal Commerce Protocol
Led by OpenAI and Stripe Google Google, Shopify and a retailer group
Launched 29 Sep 2025 16 Sep 2025 11 Jan 2026 (NRF)
Licence Apache 2.0 Apache 2.0 Apache 2.0
Core job Checkout API plus delegated payment token Signed mandates proving user authorisation Checkout, identity linking, order webhooks, token exchange
Merchant of record The merchant Not changed by the protocol "You remain the Merchant of Record"
Status (Nov 2026) Beta; stable spec 2026-04-17 v0.2; no GitHub releases Live; Stripe on the Tech Council
Where shoppers meet it ChatGPT merchant apps Google agent payments, partners AI Mode and Gemini buy buttons, Shopify stores
Latest stable ACP spec
2026-04-17
AP2 mandate types (Checkout, Payment)
2
UCP co-developers named on ucp.dev
11+
Payment companies endorsing UCP (Visa, Mastercard, Amex, PayPal, Adyen)
5

What is ACP?

The Agentic Commerce Protocol was released by OpenAI and Stripe on 29 September 2025 alongside ChatGPT Instant Checkout. Merchants implement three things: an Agentic Checkout API, the Delegate Payment spec, and shared JSON schemas. The payment side usually rides on Stripe's Shared Payment Tokens, a "scoped grant to use the customer's payment method" limited by currency, maximum amount and expiry.

OpenAI scaled back in-chat Instant Checkout in March 2026 (reports give 4, 17 or 24 March) and moved ChatGPT shopping towards discovery, per Retail Gazette. ACP itself continues: Instacart, Target, DoorDash and Expedia still run on it, and PayPal adopted it in October 2025. Full detail is in our ACP explainer.

What is AP2?

Google's AP2 launched on 16 September 2025. Its building block is the mandate, a cryptographically signed record of what you authorised. The current spec uses two:

  • a Checkout Mandate, covering what is being bought
  • a Payment Mandate, covering the payment authorisation sent towards the network

Each has an Open stage, which sets constraints in advance for autonomous buying ("running shoes under $120"), and a Closed stage, which approves one specific final checkout. The launch spec used the names Intent, Cart and Payment mandates; treat those as earlier names. AP2 is an extension of Google's A2A agent protocol, covers both human-present and human-not-present purchases, and has been donated to the FIDO Alliance. See our AP2 mandates explainer.

What is UCP?

The Universal Commerce Protocol was announced by Google at NRF on 11 January 2026. Its co-developers are Google, Shopify, Etsy, Wayfair, Target, Walmart, Amazon, Microsoft, Meta, Salesforce and Stripe, and Visa, Mastercard, Amex, PayPal and Adyen endorse it. Stripe's docs list its building blocks as checkout, OAuth identity linking, order webhooks and payment-token exchange. Google said UCP would bring a buy button to AI Mode and Gemini, paid with Google Pay, with the retailer as merchant of record.

How do they fit together?

The three overlap, but they solve different problems:

  • ACP vs UCP is the real head-to-head. Both define how an agent places an order with a store. ACP grew out of ChatGPT; UCP has the bigger retail coalition, including Amazon and Walmart. Stripe supports merchants on both.
  • AP2 sits underneath. It is about proving authorisation for the payment, and Google publishes an AP2-plus-UCP guide showing them used together.
  • Card-network programmes such as Visa Intelligent Commerce and Mastercard Agent Pay issue the tokens that these protocols carry. Stripe says Shared Payment Tokens can carry network tokens from Mastercard Agent Pay, Visa Intelligent Commerce or Amex.
  1. Google launches AP2 with mandates; Mastercard among launch partners
  2. OpenAI and Stripe release ACP with ChatGPT Instant Checkout
  3. PayPal adopts ACP for ChatGPT
  4. Google announces UCP at NRF with retail co-developers
  5. OpenAI scales back Instant Checkout; ACP continues
  6. Latest stable ACP spec version

Which card networks back which?

Mastercard was a named AP2 launch collaborator, with a quote from its chief digital officer in Google's announcement. We found no Visa statement on AP2. Both Visa and Mastercard are listed as UCP endorsers.

Which protocol matters to me as a shopper?

Mostly none of them directly. You won't pick a protocol; the agent and store do. What changes is where you can buy:

  • In ChatGPT, ACP-backed merchant apps such as Instacart and Target. See retailer apps in ChatGPT.
  • In Google AI Mode and Gemini, UCP-backed buy buttons with Google Pay.
  • With Muse, Duet and other browsing agents, mostly ordinary store checkouts using one-time cards, as described in what happens at agentic checkout.

Pros

  • All three are Apache 2.0 and published openly
  • All keep the retailer as merchant of record, so returns go to the store
  • Scoped tokens and mandates limit what an agent can spend

Cons

  • Partly overlapping, so stores may need more than one integration
  • AP2 has no tagged GitHub releases yet
  • ACP's flagship consumer feature, Instant Checkout, was scaled back

Which should a merchant implement?

Merchants have a separate decision. If ChatGPT is your priority, ACP is the route (see ACP merchant integration). If Google surfaces and Shopify matter more, UCP and AP2 (see UCP and AP2 integration). Shopify merchants get much of this through Agentic Storefronts without building anything.

Bottom line

ACP and UCP compete to be the way agents place orders with stores; AP2 is a payment-authorisation layer that can work alongside either. ACP has ChatGPT and a working set of partners, UCP has the larger retail coalition, and AP2 has Mastercard and Google behind it. For shoppers, the practical effect is the same: an approval screen, a scoped payment and a store that stays responsible for the order. For a broader primer on agent payment methods, see the AI agent payments explainer on Get Personal AI Agents.