Return something your AI agent bought the same way you would return any online order: through the store that sold it. In almost every agent setup in November 2026, the retailer, not Meta, Anthropic, OpenAI or Google, is the seller and handles returns. Your agent can often start the return for you, and if the store won't cooperate, your card's dispute rights still apply. This guide covers the steps, based on retailer and agent documentation and US consumer guidance from the CFPB and FTC. It is general information, not legal advice.

Who is responsible for returns on an agent purchase?

The merchant of record, which is the business named on your card statement and order confirmation.

How the agent bought it Who handles the return Source
Browser checkout (Muse, Claude Duet) with a one-time card The store whose site was used Store's own policy
ACP merchant app in ChatGPT The merchant ACP spec: merchant is merchant of record
UCP buy button (Google AI Mode, Gemini) The retailer UCP: "You remain the Merchant of Record"
Perplexity with PayPal The retailer Perplexity announcement
Amazon Buy for Me The brand's own store Amazon: returns "managed by the brand store"
Alexa for Shopping Amazon Amazon's standard returns

That last row matters: Amazon's Buy for Me buys from other brands' websites, and Amazon says "Delivery, returns and exchanges, and customer service are managed by the brand store." Returning through Amazon won't work. See Amazon Buy for Me.

To dispute a credit card billing error in writing (FCBA)
60 days
For the card issuer to acknowledge your dispute
30 days
For the issuer to resolve it
90 days
To report a lost debit card for the $50 liability cap
2 business days

How do I return an item my AI agent bought?

  1. Find the orderSearch your email for the store's confirmation and check your agent's activity log.
  2. Identify the sellerNote the store name on the confirmation and your card statement.
  3. Check the policyLook up the store's return window, condition rules and who pays return shipping.
  4. Start the returnUse the store's returns page, or ask your agent to start it for you.
  5. Ship and trackPrint the label, keep proof of postage and note the tracking number.
  6. Confirm the refundWatch for the refund on your card or wallet within the store's stated time.

Can I ask my agent to do the return?

Usually, yes. Most agents can navigate a store's returns portal. Expect approval prompts: Anthropic says Claude Duet always asks before deleting an order or creating an account. Physical steps, such as packing and dropping off, are still yours. A good prompt is: "Start a return for order [number] at [store]. Tell me the return window, the refund method and any fees before you submit."

What if the agent used a one-time card?

Refunds still work. The store refunds to the card it charged, and the issuer routes the money back to your underlying account. Stripe's Link documentation shows refund details on the spend request, so you can see the refund in your Link history. See how virtual cards for agents work.

If the agent signed you up for something recurring, cancel with the seller first, then revoke the card: on Link, cancelling a recurring card does not cancel the subscription itself. See how to cancel subscriptions with an AI agent.

What if the agent bought the wrong thing?

If you approved the purchase, the store will generally treat it as a normal change-of-mind return. A few tips:

  • Act fast. Return windows start at delivery or purchase, and some are short.
  • Don't open or use it if you plan to return it, where possible.
  • Keep the conversation. Your chat with the agent shows what you asked for, which helps if the store disputes the return or if the item doesn't match the listing.

If the item was misdescribed by the store, that is a stronger claim: not as described, rather than change of mind.

When should I dispute the charge instead?

Go to your card issuer if the store refuses a valid return, never ships, sends something materially different, or charges the wrong amount.

Credit cards. Under the Fair Credit Billing Act, as explained by the CFPB and the FTC:

  • Dispute billing errors in writing within 60 days of the statement date.
  • The issuer must acknowledge within 30 days and resolve within two billing cycles, and no more than 90 days.
  • You can withhold the disputed amount while it is investigated.
  • For quality problems, you generally must try to resolve it with the seller first, and the purchase must be over $50 and in your home state or within 100 miles.

Debit cards. Regulation E protections are weaker. The CFPB says liability is capped at $50 if you report a lost or stolen card within two business days, up to $500 after that, and potentially unlimited if you report more than 60 days after the statement. That is one reason to put a credit card behind your agent wallet.

PayPal. If you paid with PayPal, use its dispute process; PayPal said its buyer protections would apply to agent purchases in ChatGPT. See PayPal and AI agents.

What if I didn't approve the purchase at all?

That is an unauthorised-purchase problem rather than a return, and it needs faster action: revoke the agent's payment access, contact your issuer and change passwords. Safe AI Agents covers the security side in its AI agent safety checklist.

How do I make future returns easier?

Pros

  • Ask the agent to report the store's return policy before you approve
  • Prefer stores with free returns for items with fit or colour risk
  • Use a credit card behind your agent wallet for stronger dispute rights

Cons

  • Don't rely on the agent company to process returns; it usually can't
  • Don't let return windows lapse while waiting on the agent

Reading the approval screen carefully is the best prevention; see what happens at agentic checkout. UK readers have different rights, including Section 75 for credit card purchases over £100; see Section 75 and AI agent purchases.

Bottom line

The store that sold it handles the return, even when an AI agent placed the order. Find the confirmation, check the policy, start the return yourself or through your agent, and keep the conversation as a record. If the store won't help, dispute with your card issuer in writing within 60 days, and keep a credit card behind your agent wallet so you have the strongest protections.